Board 01 · Wood
Solid & engineered hardwood: same face, different animal.
Both are real wood on top. Underneath, they are different products with different rules about water, slabs, width, and how many times they can be sanded back to new. Choosing between them is the first real decision in a wood floor, and it is a construction decision, not a style one.
Solid hardwood
One piece of wood, typically 3/4 in. thick, tongue-and-groove, nailed or stapled to a wood subfloor. Its virtues are longevity and repairability: a solid floor can be sanded and refinished many times across a century, and it can be patched board-by-board. Its limits are moisture and geometry. Solid wood expands across its width with humidity, so wide solid planks (5 in. and up) cup and gap more visibly; it is not warranted below grade or directly over concrete in most manufacturer instructions; and it demands a controlled house, roughly 35–55% relative humidity, all year.
Engineered hardwood
A veneer of real hardwood, 2–6 mm thick, bonded to a core of cross-plied wood or HDF. The cross-ply construction restrains seasonal movement, which is why engineered can be wide, can be glued or floated, and can go over concrete and below grade where solid cannot. The honest catch is the veneer: a 2 mm veneer may tolerate one careful sanding or none; a 4–6 mm veneer behaves like solid for refinishing purposes. When a salesperson says "engineered," ask "what veneer thickness?" A floor that cannot be refinished is a disposable floor at a permanent-floor price.
Hardness, in the numbers (Janka)
| Species | Janka (lbf) | What it means at home |
|---|---|---|
| American cherry | 950 | Dents readily; darkens fast in sunlight |
| Red oak (the benchmark) | 1,290 | The reference point most floors are judged against |
| White oak | 1,360 | Slightly harder, tighter grain, takes stain evenly |
| Hard maple | 1,450 | Hard and pale; shows scratches because it is so light |
| Hickory | 1,820 | The hardest common domestic species; wild colour variation |
| Brazilian cherry (jatoba) | 2,350 | Very hard, very red, darkens dramatically |
Janka measures dent resistance, not scratch resistance. Finish hardness and lifestyle (dogs, grit, chair legs) decide surface wear; no species is immune to a dragged fridge.
Acclimation and installation, stated plainly
- Acclimation is a measurement. Wood is delivered, then checked with a pin moisture meter until it is within the manufacturer's band of the subfloor's moisture content (commonly within 2–4 percentage points). "It sat in the house for three days" is not acclimation.
- Site-finished vs prefinished. Site finishing gives a flatter, sealed-across-the-joints surface and unlimited stain choice, at the cost of days and dust. Prefinished gives a factory aluminium-oxide finish that is harder than most site finishes, with micro-bevels between boards and same-week use.
- Expansion space is structural. A typical 3/4 in. perimeter gap at walls, hidden by trim, is what keeps a humid summer from buckling the floor. A floor pinned tight to every wall is a floor waiting to tent.
- Radiant heat favours engineered, narrow widths, and quarter-sawn stock, with surface temperatures kept within the manufacturer's limit.
Price hardwood in the estimator Already have wood? Refinishing board