Board 03 · Laminate
Laminate: the hardest surface in the room, with one honest weakness.
Laminate is a photograph under a melamine wear surface, on a high-density fibreboard core. That wear surface is harder and more scratch-resistant than vinyl's, which is why laminate shrugs off dog claws and dragged chairs that mark other floors. The core is the weakness: HDF is wood fibre, and wood fibre swells when water stands at the joints.
AC ratings, the number that matters
| Rating | Duty | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| AC1–AC2 | Light / moderate residential | Bedrooms and closets only; rarely worth buying |
| AC3 | Heavy residential | The household standard; fine for living areas |
| AC4 | Light commercial | The family-with-dogs choice; halls and kitchens |
| AC5 | Commercial | Shops and offices; overkill at home, happily so |
Water, stated without varnish
"Water-resistant" laminate typically warrants standing surface water for a stated number of hours (24–72 in current ranges) before joint damage, tested in a lab, on a perfect installation. That is a real improvement on older laminate, and it is not waterproofing. A dishwasher leak that runs overnight under the cabinets defeats it, because water reaches the unsealed underside and the cut edges at the perimeter. In rooms with plumbing, laminate is a calculated risk; in dry rooms, it is one of the best value floors made.
Installation realities
- It floats, so it moves. Perimeter expansion gaps (typically 8–10 mm) and T-mouldings at long runs and doorways on big floors are required, not decorative.
- Underlayment is the feel of the floor. A decent foam or fibre underlay with a moisture barrier over concrete decides whether laminate feels solid or sounds hollow and clicky.
- Flatness again: joints peak and creak over dips. The same 3/16 in. in 10 ft discipline applies.
- It cannot be refinished and rarely repaired invisibly. Keep an attic stock of one full carton from the same dye lot; a discontinued laminate is unmatchable.
Laminate vs vinyl, in one line: laminate wins on scratches and price, vinyl wins on water and quiet. Choose by the room's real hazards, not the showroom's.